As a family of 5, we stayed in Hayworth last summer on the way to Minnesota and had a terrific time. Are there any other off-the-beaten track places we should plan to stay for one night between $200 and $250 that are a great experience and give the flavor of Wisconsin?
Wisconsin Dells is a must. Lots of cabins in area on lakes for rent. Best buy is to go before Memorial Day and my favorite is in Oct. when all the leaves change and you have the whole town to yourself.
Not sure about price but look into Door County. It's northern Wisconsin and it's beyond beautiful.