Second trip to NYC. Five days. West Village first time, staying in Harlem May. Arriving at JFK, looks like we can take public transport to Jamaica Plain, then LIRR to Penn Station? We will have access to express 2 from our rental. Also, going over to NJ on Saturday 21st for our daughters body building competition. Always looking for public transportation options. Have Uber as well.
I would also suggest taking the air train from JFK and getting on the E or A trains to Manhattan. Depending on where you are going in NJ, would suggest the Path which is very similar to subway - only goes to Hoboken, Jersey City and Newark mostly.
Love Red Rooster on 125 and Lenox!
From my personal experience, I haven't taken the LIRR to get to Manhattan yet although it does look like an option. I usually just take the AirTrain to Jamaica and then transfer to the E to get to Manhattan. You can transfer to the 2 from the E.
As for getting to New Jersey, it depends on where in New Jersey you are trying to get to. Hoboken? Newark? Jersey City? There are lots of different trains, but most of them are plugged into Google Maps, so I would just search on there. You can also adjust the time and date of the directions so you get more accurate results.
Crystal, Traveler's Toast