I'm on my buddy's bachelor party planning committee and the other groomsman and I were all pretty set on doing it in Vegas, but we got to talking about doing it in other cities as well just to do something a little less cliche. The wedding's not till next year, so we've got some time and we're open to flying anywhere within the U.S. Are there any underrated bachelor party spots that I should know about? By the way, we're not party animals at all, so it doesn't have to be as wild as Vegas either.
We haven't ruled out Vegas; just keeping open minds!
I think mountain towns make great locations for non-Vegas bachelor parties, especailly during the warmer months if you and your crew aren't big skiers or snowboarders. The top towns that come to mind are Breckenridge, Jackson Hole, Banff, and Lake Tahoe. Each has its own unique flavor, but all will provide awesome outdoor adventure activities, bars, and restaurants. You'll also have options for where to stay (renting a house or staying at a hotel).
If you want something more beach-centric and still a bit of a party, maybe try Cabo San Lucas. You can go deep sea fishing, ride ATVs, drink tequilla, and enjoy the pool and beach.
I hope this helps bachelor party locaiton brainstorming. Good luck!
Mentioned in this answer: