Hipster stuff aside, this place actually has the best Pizza I've had in New York. That's say a LOT. Also, the atmosphere is unique and has a great vibe.
For how amazing this place is and for being Michelin star-endowed, $75 for a 7-8 course prix fixe meal is a steal. I wouldn't be surprised if this restaurants ended up on Restaurant Magazine's annual list of top 50 restaurants in the world. In fact, I'm surprised that they're not on there already.
definitely a cocktail or bubbles option for the view if the weather cooperates. beware of the Veal and Lobster Sandwich if you are on a budget. It is too delicious to pass up but it will leave a dent in your wallet...$42. Yes...I said veal and lobster and bread.